Our Team

Meet The Hometown Team

At Hometown Insurance, we believe insurance is personal and the people you trust with your coverage should be people you actually know.

Our commercial and personal lines teams live and work right here in Central Indiana, proudly serving families and businesses in Brownsburg, Zionsville, Avon, and Danville. We’re your neighbors and we’re here to make sure you’re taken care of.

Take a moment to get to know us!

Dustin

CIC, Principal
Passionately Optimistic & Growth Driven. Dedicated Family Man. First generation college grad and business owner. Hunter, Fisher, & Sports Enthusiast. Former bodybuilder.

Michelle

Director of Commercial Lines
Goes above and beyond for all clients. Wife, Mom to a beautiful daughter and two crazy puppies. Have had two full time jobs for the last 13 years.

Nic E.

Commercial Agent
Outgoing and never met a stranger. Father of 2 amazingly smart/athletic boys. Loves to golf, be at the beach, and enjoy the outdoors with his kids. Has met LeBron James.

Ashley

Commercial Account Manager
Reliable. Driven. Stepmom to 3 amazing girls; Gigi to one beautiful granddaughter. A fitness enthusiast. Unapologetically avoiding anything green on my plate. Got engaged in the Colts endzone.

Lauryn

Commercial Account Manager
Bubbly. Caring, Loves to cook, bake, and be in nature. Has a degree in pre-law.

John, LUTCF

Director of Personal Lines
Driven Integrator. A Servant Leader that leads with Heart. Enjoys playing bass guitar and ocean wreck diving. Has skydived in Las Vegas.

Brian

Agent
Loves to travel. Has visited 51 countries as of 2025. Captain Morgan and Diet Coke…need I say more! Golf: love it, hate it.

Cathy

Agent/Office Manager
Dedicated. A passionate mom of two adults. Watching my favorite teams—Indy Car, Colts, Pacers, and 49ers—is my favorite way to spend the weekend. I live for the sun and the beach; give me a warm, sunny day by the water, and I’m a happy person.

Jim

President, Tackitt Insurance Agency

Kelly

Claims Specialist
Loyal & Quirky. Lover of color, design, & all things a little offbeat. Parent of 2 teens, human to a Chorkie named Twix and a queen fluff cat, Reesé. Partner in crime to a spouse who tolerates my chaos. Gave my key fob a 200,000-mile retirement party, but the car's still clocking in everyday.

Kendra

Agent & Benefits Expert
Hardworking. Trustworthy. Married over 35 years, 3 kids, 5 grandchildren. Been in insurance 25 years. Also owns a stone fabrication business offering granite & quartz countertops. Has been a referee in midget wrestling.

Matt

Account Manager
Always happy to help. Husband. Father of Three. Part of the Hometown Insurance Team since 2005.

Nate

Agent
Humorous. Outgoing. Husband. Dad. Buffalo Chicken Dip Aficionado. Is half way to seeing all 30 MLB stadiums.

Nikki

Acct. Mgr/Retention Specialist
Fun loving wife, momma, auntie and Grammy. Love to laugh and have fun. Always contains sarcasm! Happiest surrounded by family, friends, and dogs!

Nick S.

Agent
Honest. Loyal. Laid Back. Husband of 1. Father of 3. Avid comic book collector. Always looking for a good laugh!

Ronda

Account Manager
Honest. Dependable. Christian. Wife. Mother of 1. Went all the way to Colorado on a train and got stuck in a bad snow storm.

Stephanie

Customer Experience Specialist
Fitness Junkie. Loves the outdoors, hiking and being with family. Family nickname: Dory.

Steve

Agent

Annie

Marketing Director
Creative, Curly, & Entrepreneurial. Wife. Mom of 3. Manchester United fan, ukulele player, and fan of any creative project.

Marj

Front Desk/Receptionist
Follower of Jesus. Wife, Mother of 3, Mamaw to 4. Enjoys the beach and serving others.